爱问知识人 爱问教育 医院库

英语编辑的回复!

首页

英语编辑的回复!

The quality of presentation of this paper was dreadful. Ordinarily it should have been rejected. However, the subject matter is interesting and topical and the impedance plots are quite good. For these reasons, better-prepared papers were published first and it was put in the queue for consideration in the second-ranked line. 

The paper has taken about four hours to review and correct. From a technical standpoint, whether or not the results claimed are an accurate reflection of corrosion behaviour is anybody's guess, though the quality of the overall presentation does not inspire confidence.

We have a decision to take as to whether we write off the time and effort invested in reviewing and correcting this paper to get it into a state that it can be understood and assessed technically, bearing in mind its topical interest, or we reject it because it still requires further work, and even when corrected it will only constitute a mediocre paper. Alternatively, we implement the current corrections, allow the authors to make good the remaining omissions and then get the benefit of the work (we have) already done.

It was not possible to give you direct feedback on the paper until the review had been undertaken, but I would be interested to hear now if feel the author's agitation was justified? (see my earlier response).

不知道是直接被据了,还是修改后接受?谢谢各位的意见!

提交回答

全部答案

    2018-10-28 01:45:24
  •   The quality of presentation of this paper was dreadful。
    你的文章表述质量很垃圾。
    Ordinarily it should have been rejected。
      
    它本应该被拒绝。
    However, the subject matter is interesting and topical and the impedance plots are quite good。
      
    但是,这个主题很有趣,也比较反映现实,情节也不错。
    For these reasons, better-prepared papers were published first and it was put in the queue for consideration in the second-ranked line。
      
    因为这些原因,更好的准备文章会首先发表排在第二等级的列表中。

    李***

    2018-10-28 01:45:24

类似问题

换一换
  • 外语学习 相关知识

  • 教育培训
  • 教育科学
  • 教育考试

相关推荐

正在加载...
最新资料 推荐信息 热门专题 热点推荐
  • 1-20
  • 21-40
  • 41-60
  • 61-80
  • 81-100
  • 101-120
  • 121-140
  • 141-160
  • 161-180
  • 181-200
  • 1-20
  • 21-40
  • 41-60
  • 61-80
  • 81-100
  • 101-120
  • 121-140
  • 141-160
  • 161-180
  • 181-200
  • 1-20
  • 21-40
  • 41-60
  • 61-80
  • 81-100
  • 101-120
  • 121-140
  • 141-160
  • 161-180
  • 181-200
  • 1-20
  • 21-40
  • 41-60
  • 61-80
  • 81-100
  • 101-120
  • 121-140
  • 141-160
  • 161-180
  • 181-200

热点检索

  • 1-20
  • 21-40
  • 41-60
  • 61-80
  • 81-100
  • 101-120
  • 121-140
  • 141-160
  • 161-180
  • 181-200
返回
顶部
帮助 意见
反馈

确定举报此问题

举报原因(必选):